Should you book a shared catamaran or splurge on a private charter to Cayo Icacos. It comes down to group size and how much flexibility you want.
Quick Answer: For 1 to 4 people a shared catamaran ($115 to $145 each) is the better value. For groups of 6 plus, a private charter ($700 to $1,500 per boat) can match the per person price while adding privacy and a custom route. See private Icacos charters.
Shared catamaran: best for small groups
A shared catamaran costs $115 to $145 per person and includes the sail, snorkel, lunch, and open bar. For 1 to 4 people it is the clear value pick.
You share the boat with others, which is fun for some and crowded for others.
Private charter: best for bigger groups
A private charter runs $700 to $1,500 for the whole boat. For 6 plus people the per person cost approaches a shared tour, and you get privacy and a custom itinerary.
Shared tours follow a fixed schedule. Private charters let you choose departure time, how long to stay, and which cays to visit. Worth it for families with kids.
The math
2 people: shared catamaran wins on price
4 people: shared is still cheaper, private adds comfort
6 to 8 people: roughly even, private adds privacy
10 plus people: private often cheaper per person
HA
Isla Icacos Team
Local travel experts based in Fajardo and Luquillo. We sail every catamaran and snorkel every reef personally to bring you honest reviews and real recommendations.
